Our daily menu consists of 8 basic cookies to satisfy your sweet cravings plus a trio of brownies. We use top quality, all natural ingredients, no preservatives, and make these with love and care.
COOKIES
1. Iced Sugar Cookie Cut-outs--a tender, crisp, buttery, vanilla sugar cookie with white royal icing. This is John's favorite cookie and the one that started the idea to create a cookie business.
$3.50 a dozen
2. Vanilla Shortbread--a tender, buttery, melt in your mouth shortbread, which is lightly sweetened and a classic treat when you want just a little something sweet. Great with tea or coffee.
$3.50 a dozen
3. Key Lime Vanilla cookies--bursting with tangy citrus flavor, this little gem of a vanilla butter cookie is a tribute to the classic flavor of Key Lime pie. You have to try this. It is so refreshing.
$4.00 a dozen
4. Chocolate Oat Chip-- this cookie is a wonderfully chewy chocolate chip cookie, with a hint of oats and tons of chocolate chips. This cookie is a special one as half the profits go towards Pediatric Cancer treatment research. Read more here.
$4.50 a dozen
5. Triple Peanut Butter Chip --we have added rich roasted peanut butter flavor 3 different ways in this cookie with chunky and smooth peanut butters and peanut butter chips. It is a winner with our dad, who is quite picky about his peanut butter cookies.
$4.00 a dozen
6. Oatmeal Cranberry White Chocolate-- a wonderful, chewy oatmeal cookie loaded with sweet dried cranberries and white chocolate chips.
$4.00 a dozen
7. Gingersnaps-- a wonderfully flavorful ginger cookie that is slightly chewy in texture. These are Nathan’s favorite cookie. $4.00 a dozen
8. Oatmeal Raisin--a classic chewy oatmeal cookie with plump juicy golden raisins. You can ask for walnuts to be added if you would like nuts. $4.00 a dozen
9. Snickerdoodles-- This is a thick, soft, sugar-and-cinnamon spiced vanilla cookie that you don't have to save for the holidays. Our recipe is tops. $4.00 a dozen.
BROWNIES
Turtle Brownies--a rich fudge brownie base topped with our mom’s homemade salted caramel and toasted chopped pecans. You will get a “sheet” of brownies that measures 6.5 inches by 9 inches for you to cut into pieces. You can get at least a dozen 2 in. by 2 in. pieces from this sheet $7.50
Buckeye Brownies--a rich fudge brownie base swirled with a rich peanut butter fudge filling. If you like peanut butter cups, then this will be a treat. You will get a “sheet” of brownies that measures 6.5 inches by 9 inches for you to cut into pieces. You can get at least a dozen 2 in. by 2 in. pieces from this sheet. $7.50
Fudge Brownies-- a rich fudge brownie that needs no extra adornments. You will get a “sheet” of brownies that measures 6.5 inches by 9 inches for you to cut into pieces. You can get at least a dozen 2 in. by 2 in. pieces from this sheet. $6.50
How to Order:
We take orders via phone (2pm-7pm) and email Friday-Monday.
Email: twobrotherscookie@outlook.com
We can only bake 10-15 dozen cookies in a week so get your orders in early! This is an after school business right now so we are limited to what we can produce.
Large individual orders (more than 4 dozen) need at least a week's notice for us to plan production.
How we deliver cookies:
If you go to church with us we can deliver your cookies to you on Wednesday nights.
All other cookies will be delivered on Thursday afternoons (3pm) at a designated location.
Please note that at this time we cannot take cookie orders to be shipped out of town.
